Reply to: “Ice cap thaw may awaken Icelandic volcanoes”

Reply to: “Ice cap thaw may awaken Icelandic volcanoes” Steven Goddard tugs on his alleged “volcano researcher and igneous petrologist” hat to declare that melting Icelandic ice caps will actually make the volcanoes less dangerous. Of course it’s always easier to nit-pick over a magazine article than it is to do the same to the scientific paper it is based on.

Steven discusses the melting point of basaltic minerals (failing to recognize that Icelandic magma also contains the more explosive rhyolitic minerals) and estimates that losing 500m of ice would only lower the magma melting point by about 0.5°C. Then he wanders off into an irrelevant discussion of ash and steam. With less ice/water around there would less volcanic plume and more bubbling, so Global Warming would be good! Like most denialist arguments, this is both inconsequential and irrelevant.

As it turns out, in Iceland the magma is rising at roughly 5 cm/yr and the glacial mass loss equates to removing  5 cm/yr of rock. Thus the effective rate of magma ascent has doubled due to de-glaciation. Doesn’t seem inconsequential to me…

Nice try, Steven. But I’m glad to see you didn’t miss the chance to make a snide allusion to Al Gore’s recent misstatement about the temperature of the earth’s core. Snap!

One thought on “Reply to: “Ice cap thaw may awaken Icelandic volcanoes”

  1. “volcano researcher and igneous petrologist”

    . . . but he doesn’t tell us where he worked, or what he did, or who supervised him, or if he ever published anything (ha!) I’m sure if the answers of any of these questions reflected credit on him, they’d be front and center. I call ownership rock tumbler in the basement and one trip to Mt Saint Helens when he was ten.

    [When I first became active in the Global Warming debate I stumbled onto WUWT and was astonished at the fanaticism there. I commented a few times before the malicious edits of my comments destroyed what little credibility the site had as a point of interaction (not of information). One of the things I tried to do was to ascertain Steven Goddard’s academic credentials because he said so many geologically stupid things. Steven ducked and bobbed, refusing to provide any credible experience… – Ben]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s