Australia’s white summer, Monbiot’s red fury

Australia’s white summer, Monbiot’s red fury. Watt a surprise, Anthony Watts drawing our attention to a freak weather event in Australia. This must surely prove that there’s no Global Warming! Anthony also stretches his mental capacity to compare the size of Australia to America and to Europe. Anthony is mad that environmental reporter George Monbiot consulted “the kids at the Climate Rapid Response Team“, aka professional climate scientists, to understand this Australian weather. How dare he!

Don’t you know that if you cherry-pick a small enough smoothing radius you can make big holes appear in the global temperature data maps? I’m surprised that Anthony doesn’t try to claim that all smoothing is false and present a temperature data map with 99.9% “no data”.

Changing your color scheme to assign ‘bluer’ colors to warm temperatures also helps make things look ‘cooler’. Presumably Anthony thinks that every year those corrupt mainstream climatologists have been slightly changing their color schemes to look make the same temperatures look ‘redder’.


Hmmm... Dr. Spencer's map is pretty red. He must be in on the plot now too.


Anthony has to come up with something to distract from the fact that 2010 has proven the hottest year in the instrument record even with only a moderate El Niño influence. (Note: who cares about one year? That’s a denialist distraction. It’s the long-term trend that matters.)

Further more, we learn that the weather stations in remote Greenland communities are clearly affected by the urban heat island effect. Anthony’s speculation proves it! (Maybe this particular rant was a bit of nostalgia for the old days when Anthony regularly tried to get away with this UHI b.s.)

2 thoughts on “Australia’s white summer, Monbiot’s red fury

  1. “Australia’s white summer, Monbiots’s red fury” (WUWT, Dec 20, 2010)

    The response is the same now as it was to Steve Goddard’s original (May17-Jun15) six-part assault on GISS.

    “…The differences that have developed between the GISS and HadCRUT global temperatures during the past decade are due primarily to the extension of the GISS analysis into regions excluded from the HadCRUT analysis.”

    “…HadCRUT implicitly assumes that areas without observations have a temperature anomaly equal to the hemispheric mean anomaly. Given the pattern of large temperature anomalies in the fringe Arctic areas with data, this implicit estimate surely understates the effect of Arctic temperature anomalies.”

    Section 7: Comparison of GISS, NCDC, and HadCRUT (page 14)
    (Previous references to this paper were to earlier drafts)

    Click to access 2010_Hansen_etal.pdf

  2. Of course, fast forward two weeks and now Australia is under water. The poular comparison seems to be that an area the size of France and Germany (combined) is now under flood waters. Several have died and several hundreds of thousands are in areas with no road access.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s