Some reactions to the CLOUD experiment

Some reactions to the CLOUD experiment” (2011-08-25). Strangely Anthony Watts’ selection of “reactions” to the preliminary results of CERN’s CLOUD experiment are all denialist or sympathetic. “Some” means “the ones we like” I guess. Just another day in Anthony’s cramped mind…

5 thoughts on “Some reactions to the CLOUD experiment

  1. Wow! Most interesting post you’ve had.

    I read Real Climate about CLOUD, also.

    Mostly, I *suspect* the CLOUD folk are correct: it’s the sun.

    (Doesn’t Piers Corbyn make a zillion bucks working for the banksters who bet on corn futures, etc, by telling them what the weather is *really* gonna be? ….because NOAA, the Met Office, etc. etc. can’t predict the seasons, but he does, year after year?)
    ….Lady in Red

    • “Mostly, I *suspect* the CLOUD folk are correct: it’s the sun.”

      As I posted below, they are saying no such thing.

      As for Piers Corbyn, he’s a fraud. His “methodology” – which he has never revealed and refuses to discuss in anything but the most generalized statements – is not much more than astrology. He claims success even when his predictions fail. Not content to limit his voodoo to dubious solar/weather connections, he has recently added the Moon to his “calculations”. When will the stars be next? His beef isn’t just with climate scientists, it’s with the science of meteorology. He’s been predicting cooling for years now, and it hasn’t happened. He has been claiming that “the last 7 years” have cooled for a number of years already – he just regurgitates the same 7 year figure every year and hopes (correctly when it comes to his target audience) that nobody will notice. He’s a joke. Piers Corbyn wouldn’t know what science was if it bit him on the posterior.

  2. Here’s a reaction to the CERN experiment, from the lead author, Dr Jasper Kirkby:

    “Our work leaves open the possibility that cosmic rays could influence the climate. However, at this stage, there is absolutely no way we can say that they do.” – The Guardian

    “Early results seem to indicate that cosmic rays do cause a change. The high-energy protons seemed to enhance the production of nanometre-sized particles from the gaseous atmosphere by more than a factor of ten. But, Kirkby adds, those particles are far too small to serve as seeds for clouds. “At the moment, it actually says nothing about a possible cosmic-ray effect on clouds and climate, but it’s a very important first step.” he says.” – Nature

    • It sounds like the chances are pretty low that the cosmic rays will produce particles big enough to seed clouds. I guess the next step is to try seeding clouds with similar particles in varying amounts to see the results in the real atmosphere? Or maybe bombard the atmosphere with varying amounts of EM and nuclear radiation to see if we can seed clouds? If that works, farmers would love being able to produce possible rain clouds on demand (doubtful, though).

      Real skepticism means looking into this cosmic ray affect realizing it may indeed have a bit of a contribution to climate, but at the same time we don’t throw out the knowledge we have about CO2 and its primary affect on the climate record.

  3. James Delingpole, of the UK Daily Telegraph, his reaction to the CERN Experiment is as follows:

    “If Michael Crichton had lived to write a follow-up to State of Fear, the plotline might well have gone like this: at a top secret, state of the art laboratory in Switzerland, scientists finally discover the true cause of “global warming”.” – Sun Causes Climate Change Shock

    Truly bizarre!

    Perhaps James, either could not, would not understand, get or deliberately chose to ignore, Dr. Scott Denning’s latest epic message!

    [epic face palm]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s